Doctor of Philosophy, Miami University, 2017, Psychology
Very little is known about the underlying neural mechanisms of individual differences in judgment and reasoning ability, and even less work has been done to investigate neural correlates of dual-processing. According to many dual-processing theories, type 2 processing in judgment and reasoning relies heavily on cognitive control. Two particular patterns of neural activity, frontal midline theta (FMT) and fronto-parietal theta coherence, have been related to cognitive control in several different paradigms. As such, they presented candidates for neural correlates of type 2 processing. Additionally, working memory capacity has been linked to FMT, fronto-parietal theta coherence, and performance on judgment and reasoning tasks. However, the relationship between these variables had not been tested in previous research. Across two experiments, working memory capacity failed to predict FMT or fronto-parietal theta coherence, but did predict more logical fallacies and semantic coherence in Experiment 2. Judgment ability was measured through the number of conjunction and disjunction fallacies committed, as well as semantic coherence, a stricter benchmark of judgment ability that measures how well participants' responses correspond to the type of probability set described in the problem In Experiment 1, FMT predicted more logical fallacies and more semantic coherence, reflecting higher levels of cognitive control. In Experiment 2, there was less fronto-parietal theta coherence in identical sets compared to other types of probability sets, which require more cognitive control, supporting the link between fronto-parietal theta coherence and cognitive control. However, neither FMT nor fronto-parietal theta coherence predicted logical fallacies or semantic coherence in Experiment 2. Together, these experiments provide preliminary evidence that FMT and fronto-parietal theta coherence are important for cognitive control in judgment and reasoning tasks, but no evidence that they ar (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Christopher Wolfe Dr. (Committee Chair); Robin Thomas Dr. (Committee Co-Chair); Joseph Johnson Dr. (Committee Member); Anne Farrell Dr. (Committee Member)
Subjects: Cognitive Psychology