Doctor of Philosophy, The Ohio State University, 2016, EDU Teaching and Learning
The notion of scaffolding is commonly referred to in educational research and practice, however there is little empirical evidence on its role in literacy learning, and even less so in the context of early writing. Additionally, of the empirical work on the topic, scaffolding is often used as synonymous with any form of guidance or support. Therefore, bringing the theoretical tenets of the scaffolding metaphor to bear, this study examined the nature of and relationship between teachers' scaffolding, in particular the teacher's instructional and domain contingency during writing, and first grade students' writing outcomes.
Data sources were taken from an extant dataset and included 56 videos of 24 teachers working one-to-one with 25 first grade students during the writing portion of the Reading Recovery lesson, students' pre and post assessment data on three measures of writing, lesson records, and student writing samples. Problem-solving cycles in which the teacher and child interacted on a particular writing-related content were transcribed and coded in terms of instructional contingency, how the teacher adjusted her degree of control in response to the student, and domain contingency, which referred to the content focus of the interaction and the overall appropriateness of the teaching moves in the problem-solving cycle.
Hierarchical and stepwise regression were used to determine whether the proportion of instructionally and domain contingency moves and cycles accounted for any variance in the students' writing outcome scores above and beyond entry score. Results of the hierarchical regression indicated that neither the proportion of instructionally contingent moves, nor the proportion of cycles rated as good teaching moves had a significant impact on exit Writing Vocabulary, Hearing and Recording Sounds in Words, or Early Writing Observational Rubric score, nor did the teacher's shift in degrees of control within opportunities for contingency. However, s (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Emily Rodgers Ph.D (Advisor); Jerome D'Agostino Ph.D (Committee Member); Ian Wilkinson Ph.D. (Committee Member)
Subjects: Education; Literacy