Doctor of Education (Educational Leadership), Youngstown State University, 2024, Department of Teacher Education and Leadership Studies
Historically, minority students have been overrepresented in special education programming in the United States (Fletcher, 2014; Wright & Wright, 2021). This study describes how several external historical, theoretical, and practical factors beyond academic challenges impact special education qualification rates for minority students compared to their non-minority counterparts. It also considers these factors through the lens of implicit bias, cultural misunderstandings, and misinterpretations of disability categories, like emotional disturbance.
The study outlines these contexts by exploring Disability Critical Race (DisCrit) Theory, Cultural Ecological Theory, and Social Learning Theory to understand the social and cultural influences that further lead to the issue of overrepresentation. Prior research suggests that lack of cultural awareness, potential implicit bias mindsets, and other issues beyond students' development and control contribute to the disproportionate representation of minority students in special education (Breese et al., 2023; Kreskow, 2013).
This mixed-methods study utilizes Q-methodology and a questionnaire to examine external root causes and systemic issues related to influences regarding the special education evaluative process for minority groups, specifically Black students and emotional disturbance. By examining the perspectives of education professionals, this study aims to recognize the need for considerations of cultural responsiveness, effective self-reflective practices, ongoing professional development, and innovative systems that address the whole child before the special education evaluative process begins.
The results of the study reveal significant concerns related to the special education evaluative processes regarding consideration of external factors, overall consistency, procedural misunderstanding, and issues related to cultural differences. These findings from a theoretical context indicate a need for understandin (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Karen Larwin PhD (Advisor); Luther Johnson EdD (Committee Member); Patrick Spearman PhD (Committee Member)
Subjects: Special Education