Doctor of Philosophy, The Ohio State University, 2020, English
This dissertation challenges the standard narrative of nineteenth-century literary secularization by attending to British texts that engage liturgy and ritual. According to once standard accounts of secularization, the development of modernity—the rise of the natural sciences, the spread of market economies, and so forth—necessarily entails the decline and eventual demise of religion. Until recently, many readings of Romantic and Victorian literature have assumed this trajectory of progressive secularization. However, for the last twenty years, scholarship from a variety of disciplines—history, sociology, anthropology, philosophy, and theology—has complicated and often rejected the notion that modernization brings about the death of faith. Such scholarship frequently observes how the concept of religion itself—especially when construed as private belief in supernatural ideas—is a construction of early modern Europe and is born simultaneously with the notion of the secular as the sphere of public reason.
Drawing on these recent revisions of secularization theory, I ask why—in a so-called age of doubt—many nineteenth-century writers of various confessional stances nevertheless become fascinated by liturgy and ritual. Rather than simply accept the picture of religion as primarily an interior, otherworldly phenomenon, these writers, I argue, turn to liturgy to enflesh faith—that is, to resist modernity's characteristic bifurcations of natural/supernatural, body/soul, reason/faith, and so on. At once spiritual and material, liturgy incarnates unseen realities in concrete forms—bread, wine, water, the architectural arrangement of churches and temples, and the temporal patterns of ritual calendars. Romantic and Victorian writers deploy this incarnational power for a host of reasons: to reinvest the natural world and material objects with spiritual meaning, to reimagine the human person as porous and malleable rather than as closed and mechanical, to question the homoge (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Clare Simmons (Advisor); David Riede (Committee Member); Amanpal Garcha (Committee Member); Norman Jones (Committee Member)
Subjects: British and Irish Literature; Literature; Religion; Theology