Doctor of Philosophy, The Ohio State University, 2024, Spanish and Portuguese
This dissertation addresses the question of how we should approach the study of identity to advance the emancipatory goals in Latin American and Latinx studies. In answering this question, I aim to shed light on the debate about identity and its intricate connections with culture, language, and power—core themes in the humanities and social sciences. This dissertation intervenes in this debate both at the metatheoretical level—aiming to rethink the philosophical presuppositions that guide our theorizing, determine our questions, problems, values, and goals—and at the theoretical level—aiming to restructure the analytic concepts we use in our thinking.
Chapter 1 critically engages with Nestor Garcia Canclini's "Culturas Hibridas", where he argues that “hybridity,” rather than “identity,” should be used to study cultural forms. By identifying the critical ontological, epistemic, linguistic, and axiological questions that any research paradigm must address, I aim to characterize both modern and postmodern paradigms and identify their potential problems. Specifically, I critique the postmodern paradigm's descriptivist view of language and metaphysics of chaos. I propose a pragmatist research paradigm that highlights the normative functions of discourse of identity, arguing that terms like “identity,” “hybridity,” and “authenticity” are better understood as linguistic devices used to negotiate cultural practices.
Chapter 2 shifts focus to Latinx studies, examining Gloria Anzaldua's notion of “new mestiza consciousness.” This chapter aims to assess the theoretical and political adequacy of mestizaje, clarify the challenge of essentialism for emancipatory research, examine the influence of postmodern values on Latinx research, and showcase the philosophical advantages of a pragmatist approach combined with Systemic Functional Linguistics. I trace the emergence of Latinx studies and the importance of emancipatory values. By critically evaluating mestizaje, essentialism a (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Ignacio Corona (Advisor); Fernando Unzueta (Committee Member); Paloma Martinez-Cruz (Committee Member)
Subjects: Ethnic Studies; Hispanic American Studies; Latin American Literature; Latin American Studies