Doctor of Philosophy, The Ohio State University, 2024, Communication
Scholars have long interrogated the boundary between possessions and the self. In this tradition, Belk (1988) proposed self-extension as the extent to which “we regard our possessions as parts of ourselves” (p. 139). A growing literature has applied it to possessions that are almost always on the self: mobile communication technologies. The transition from cellphones to smartphones has expanded how mobile communication technology informs and reflects the self. Accordingly, an increasing number of studies have examined smartphone self-extension. However, extant work suggests that smartphone self-extension is only loosely related to actual smartphone behavior, calling its real-world impact into question. This dissertation clarifies how self-extension relates to behavior by examining more granular and theoretically grounded behaviors derived from a large, multi-faceted dataset of digital traces. I integrate work on smartphone self-extension and extended cognition to provide rationale for hypotheses linking smartphone self-extension with digital trace measures. I measure smartphone self-extension based on its original functional, anthropomorphic, and ontological dimensions (Park & Kaye, 2019) as well as an identity dimension, which subsumes the anthropomorphic and ontological dimensions (Ross & Bayer, 2021). The digital trace measures include overall frequency of smartphone use, frequencies of using smartphone functions, variety of smartphone functions, smartphone use across spatial contexts, smartphone use across temporal contexts, and potential for reactibility. Ontological self-extension received partial support across almost all hypotheses and research questions; identity self-extension retained some of these relationships; anthropomorphic self-extension was only positively associated with certain frequencies of using smartphone functions (particularly social media); and functional self-extension was unrelated to digital trace measures. These findings were generally (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Joseph Bayer (Advisor); Roselyn Lee-Won (Committee Member); David DeAndrea (Committee Member)
Subjects: Communication