PhD, University of Cincinnati, 2022, Education, Criminal Justice, and Human Services: Criminal Justice
The goal of the Sentencing Reform Act of 1984 was to eliminate (or at the very least reduce) extralegal disparities in federal sentencing outcomes, including those based on race/ethnicity and district. Despite this goal, post-guideline research demonstrates that racial/ethnic minorities continue to receive harsher sentences than Whites and some districts continue to sentence harsher than others (net of relevant factors). Although past works have acknowledged these persistent extralegal differences, extant works have devoted surprisingly little attention to how these disparities have shifted over time. This is a particularly important “gap” in the literature given the sweeping changes to the federal criminal justice system (and the United States more broadly) since the implementation of the federal sentencing guidelines in 1987. Explicitly, since guideline implementation there have been numerous legal (e.g., Supreme Court decisions, pieces of legislation), priority (e.g., waning focus on drugs, increased focus on immigration), and societal changes (e.g., rising minority populations, shifting drug epidemics) which have implications for racial/ethnic- and district-based disparity.
To this end, the goal of this dissertation is to answer two questions. First, how has the influence of defendant race/ethnicity on federal sentencing outcomes changed over time? Second, how have the effects of district, and district-level predictors, on federal sentencing outcomes changed over time? To answer these questions, I combine numerous publicly available datasets at the case-, district-, and time-level. At the case-level, I use 19 consecutive years (1998 to 2016) of federal sentencing data from the USSC Monitoring of Federal Criminal Sentences (MFCS) data series. At the district-level, I use data from the Administrative Office of the United States Courts, United States Census Bureau, and MIT Election Data and Science Lab. Meanwhile, at the time-level, I use the MFC (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Ben Feldmeyer Ph.D. (Committee Member); John Wooldredge Ph.D. (Committee Member); Jeffery Ulmer Ph.D. (Committee Member); James Frank Ph.D. (Committee Member)
Subjects: Criminology