Doctor of Philosophy, Case Western Reserve University, 2019, English
The English Renaissance was literary, ecclesiastical, and charged with references to afflictions, both physical and spiritual. Yet while it is often central to religious doxology and instruction, affliction is not an art that can be monopolized by a single religious doctrine or denomination. It was possible, in other words, for early modern English poets to turn to both Catholic and Protestant predecessors for an understanding of spiritual affliction, despite the dramatic religious, political, and social upheavals that came before. In the psalm translations of Sir Philip Sidney and Mary Sidney Herbert, Countess of Pembroke; the Salve Deus Rex Judaeorum of Aemilia Lanyer, the Devotions upon Emergent Occasions of John Donne, and The Temple of George Herbert, these poets attended to a nexus of suffering and artistic expression in order to lead their readers toward theological instruction. They do so through what I call an “afflictive poetics,” a rhetorical mode in which the poet offers this theological instruction through a series of poetic forms, figures, and perspectives that depend upon a demonstration of spiritual and physical or physiological suffering. These works were all written or published in roughly the period between 1580 and 1633, beginning with the writing of Sidney's Defence of Poesy and ending with the posthumous publication of Donne's Poems and Herbert's Temple. Despite all being nominally Protestant, the poets examined in this dissertation represent a broad spectrum of religious beliefs and practices. In arguing for the importance of afflictive poetics, I join the continuing “religious turn” in early modern literary studies, particularly in the branch that recognizes the ambiguity of confessional categories and attends to the experience of the individual believer. In doing so, I tend to eschew debates focused on denominational, doctrinal, and doxological disputes, which often robs us of the richness of the poetry and the relationship that develops bet (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Christopher Flint Dr. (Committee Chair); Maggie Vinter Dr. (Committee Member); Erika Olbricht Dr. (Committee Member); Timothy Wutrich Dr. (Committee Member)
Subjects: Literature