Doctor of Philosophy, The Ohio State University, 2024, English
"Playing with Comics: Material Culture in the Hands of 20th-Century American Readers" examines how 20th-century newspaper comic strips and comic books encouraged readers to play with their contents and, subsequently, how readers reproduced, altered, and transformed comics content through their play practices. I argue play has an essential and productive role in our experience reading comics, and yet the visual and narrative tools provided by 20th-century comics were used in personalized ways shaped by individual contexts. Drawing from original archival research, this project seeks to answer two sets of questions: (1) How did comics create opportunities for play, and how did they imagine readers would respond to their invitations? (2) How did readers actually play with comics, and how did material, social, cultural, and historical contexts shape that play?
In "Playing with Comics," play is defined through the intertwined processes of imagining oneself and others through printed content and the interpretation of those materials within personal contexts. Inspired by Rebecca Wanzo's work in The Content of Our Caricature (2020), I argue that the character types in comics provided one of the primary tools for play, and comics' invitations were defined through the visual logic of two distinct yet interconnected types: the idealized caricature and the undesirable stereotype. These character types served as models for readers' play, and my analyses investigate how idealized caricatures functioned as models for imitation and encouraged readers to imagine their own transformations while undesirable stereotypes restricted opportunities for play and reinforced racial, ethnic, and gendered stereotypes. The visual markers of identity and their associated narratives were reinforced through mechanical and ideological reproduction, but character types also relied on those readers who played with and within these types. As a result, the contexts in which readers encountered and pla (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Jared Gardner (Advisor); Robyn Warhol (Committee Member); Caitlin McGurk (Committee Member)
Subjects: American History; American Studies; Gender; Mass Media