Master of Arts, The Ohio State University, 2020, Bioethics
For decades, discussions related to informed consent have been at the forefront of medical research. Guidelines, protocols, and regulations have evolved and continue to be modified at national and international levels. However, while the specifics of informed consent have been defined in more detail when testing is conducted on live research participants, there has been little written about what informed consent should consist of when it comes to whole-body donation and who should provide that consent. With other research projects, there are several international guidelines along with federal regulations that specify the extent of information that must be provided to participants (Nuremburg Code, Declaration of Helsinki, Belmont Report, Common Rule). Federal protections for whole-body donors are nearly absent and state regulations vary greatly and are often minimal. Commonly, donors consent to their body being used for “educational and research purposes” which conveys minimal information at best to the donor or donor's family as to what will happen with the body. In parts of the United States, the bodies of unclaimed dead are still used for research, absent any type of informed consent. Furthermore, when the studies have been completed, it is not always clear if all or only part of the human remains will be cremated and returned to the family. When consent is obtained from the person donating their own body, should medical institutions also be required to receive informed consent from those who possess the legal right of disposition since what happens to the body is generally a concern to the family? The literature addressing these questions appears to be minimal or even absent. This thesis addresses these issues and others in an attempt to bring more transparency and accountability to whole-body donation and to stimulate further discussion of these topics. Just as respect for live research participants takes precedence over the results of the studies in which they (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Dana Howard PhD (Advisor); Courtney Thiele JD, MA (Committee Member); Joy Balta MSc, MATLHE, Phd (Committee Member)
Subjects: Ethics; Health Education; Health Sciences; Human Remains; Medical Ethics; Medicine