Doctor of Philosophy, Case Western Reserve University, 2016, Management
The rich store of audit quality research and steady improvements to auditing standards over the decades have not yielded the desired impact on audit quality. While most litigations following corporate failure naming auditors as defendants tend to accuse auditors of lack of independence, objectivity and willful participation in fraud, the impact of these character dimensions on audit quality has not been fully explored. Professional accounting bodies impress upon their members to be independent in fact and in appearance, be objective and exhibit integrity in their decisions about their clients' financials statement, yet, not much is known about how independence, objectivity, and integrity impact audit quality. Secondly, not much is known about how auditors enact independence, objectivity, and integrity on an audit engagement. Also, inputs from auditors have been quite underutilized in audit quality research in recent years, yet auditors are the people who implement changes in auditing standards and regulations. This dissertation focuses on the very character dimensions that auditors tend to be accused of lacking to examine the impact of independence, objectivity, integrity, and environmental constraints on audit quality.
Guided by institutional theory and the theory of negotiated order, a multi-staged, three-part sequential mixed methods study consisting of one quantitative and two qualitative studies were conducted using responses from audit managers. Survey responses from auditors in the United Kingdom and the United States were used to perform an exploratory theoretical study of the impact of Independence, Objectivity, Integrity, and Constraints on Audit Quality. The second study was conducted to identify a highly constrained business environment where the impact of Independence, Objectivity, and Integrity on Audit Quality could be validated. Following the second study, a third study was conducted to understand the effects of the institutional environment on au (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Richard Boland Jr (Committee Chair); Timothy Fogarty (Committee Member); Kalle Lyytinen (Committee Member); Nicholas Berente (Committee Member)
Subjects: Accounting