Doctor of Philosophy, The Ohio State University, 2015, EDU Teaching and Learning
Writing from sources is viewed as a fundamental component of academic literacy as well as developing connections between reading and writing. An especially challenging task of source-based writing is synthesizing, which requires careful selection, organization and integration of sources. Given the significance of synthesizing in developing multilingual students' academic literacy in English, this study examined the teaching and learning of synthesis writing in a university L2 composition course. Within a multidimensional view of literacy and discourses of writing, I conducted classroom-based qualitative multiple case studies, in which both the teacher's experience with synthesis instruction and four Chinese undergraduate students' engagement in synthesis writing were examined. Guided by the constructivist model of discourse synthesis–organizing, selecting and connecting (Spivey, 1990, 1997)–from the L1 composition literature, I investigated the teacher's task representation of synthesis, the students' developmental trajectories of learning to write a synthesis, and the individual and contextual factors that contributed to their varied writing abilities while approaching synthesis tasks.
Over a five-month period comprising one academic semester, I collected multiple sources of data, including semi-structured interviews, stimulated-recall protocols, writing samples, recordings of teacher-student writing tutorials, classroom observation field notes, course-related documents and artifacts, and surveys. These data were analyzed inductively and triangulated to explore different aspects of the teaching and learning of synthesis writing. The findings of the study revealed that both the teacher's task representation of synthesis and the students' products and processes of synthesis writing involved the three operations–organizing, selecting and connecting–albeit to various degrees among the student participants. Thus, it appears that the constructivist model of discourse (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Alan Hirvela Ph.D. (Advisor); George Newell Ph.D. (Committee Member); Lin Ding Ph.D. (Committee Member)
Subjects: Composition; Education; English As A Second Language; Literacy; Pedagogy; Teaching