Doctor of Philosophy, The Ohio State University, 2014, Music
Is one of the most common approaches to intervention in the realm of culture in recent years – the safeguarding of tradition – the right path to take? In this dissertation, I argue that it is not, and that a different formulation of goals and methods is necessary. Using a case study of Jemaa el Fnaa Square in Marrakech, Morocco, I discuss the flawed concepts contained within the idea of safeguarding, outline their consequences, and put forth an alternative possibility for how things might be done differently.
As a focus for criticism of the safeguarding approach, I will discuss UNESCO's Intangible Cultural Heritage program, arguably the most internationally powerful institutional voice in the area of the conserving cultural practices. Since the Declarations of Masterpieces in 2001, 2003, and 2005 and the highly successful 2003 ICH Convention, the UNESCO paradigms of Intangible Cultural Heritage and "safeguarding" have become influential concepts in international, national, and local cultural policy. However, this concept of safeguarding attempts to impose onto the flow of human activity a way of thinking better suited to physical sites: culture as a static edifice with clear boundaries that is under threat of erosion, with safeguarding as a process of "shoring up." This results in an awkward fit of both theory and practice that leads to projects with unattainable goals, poorly-directed resources, and limited benefits for their intended recipients.
As an alternative framework for intervention, I will discuss the Capability Approach, initially developed by economist Amartya Sen. The capabilities approach seeks ways of enhancing the possible range of choices and abilities of individuals and communities, privileging it over the prescribing of particular activities as a goal and evaluative space. This approach is well-suited to projects relating to culture, which is a fluid and dynamic process resistant to static, prescriptive notions. I will discuss ways in whi (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Udo Will (Advisor); Danielle Fosler-Lussier (Committee Member); Dorothy Noyes (Committee Member)
Subjects: African Studies; Cultural Resources Management; Folklore; Middle Eastern Studies; Music; North African Studies