Doctor of Philosophy, The Ohio State University, 2020, Comparative Studies
Fan communities, once considered marginal, have become an object of study across many academic disciplines. While considerable energy has been devoted to studying fans' creative works, little work has attended to religiosity in fandom, beyond superficial comparisons of fan behaviors to religious ones. As yet, no one has produced an analysis of this relationship addressing the complexity of a subculture that behaves religiously (by any academic understanding) but does not usually identify itself as religious. This dissertation examines the religious nature of fan practices as seen in pilgrimages related to the mega- franchises Harry Potter, Doctor Who, and Sherlock. The aim is not merely to demonstrate that these pilgrimages are religious, but also to explicate how religiosity works in such non-traditional contexts--that is, through pilgrimages in commercial and ordinary spaces that make no claim to transcendent authority. This analysis questions assumptions about what makes a shrine a shrine, a community religious, or a narrative or ritual an expression of values and belief.
This research examines seven fan pilgrimage sites using ethnographic data, including participant observation, surveys, and interviews. Sites include the Wizarding World of Harry Potter in Orlando, FL; the Warner Bros. Studio Tour London: The Making of Harry Potter; Platform 9 3/4 at King's Cross Station in London, UK; filming locations and sites that inspired the Harry Potter movies in Oxford, UK; the Doctor Who Experience, Cardiff, UK; Ianto's Shrine, Cardiff, UK; and the memorial to Sherlock Holmes at St Bartholomew's Hospital, London, UK. Analysis focuses on three themes: creation of sacred space, imagined community, and emergences of belief in ritual and other actions common to fan pilgrimage and traditional religious pilgrimage. Drawing on studies of religion and popular culture, folk belief, fan culture, and narrative theory, this interdisciplinary investigation of fan pilgrimages adv (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Hugh B. Urban (Advisor); Katherine Borland (Committee Member); Merrill Kaplan (Committee Member); Isaac Weiner (Committee Member); Ross P. Garner (Committee Member)
Subjects: Folklore; Mass Media; Religion