Master of Science (MS), Ohio University, 2023, Journalism (Communication)
This study examines the media representation of Indigenous communities in the context
of environmental issues in three media outlets: Indian Country Today, High Country
News, and the New York Times. By using Indigenous Standpoint Theory as a framework,
the work seeks to elevate Indigenous voices in the debates on environmental justice.
Through Carvalho's framework (2008) of Critical Discourse Analysis, the study considered
a variety of manifest textual elements and used them to infer multiple underlying
discursive strategies and ideological convictions of the journalists of the different outlets.
The results of this study show that media outlets with Indigenous journalists in their
newsrooms focus more on empowering Indigenous communities through highlighting
their knowledge, their relationships with their lands and their grievances for justice.
Providing historical context amplified Indigenous demands, while considering the power
imbalances between colonizers and colonized. In contrast, the New York Times' coverage
fell short in portraying Indigenous communities and their claims for environmental justice
in a nuanced, contextualized way. Their reporting focused on conflict and negativity,
which thwarts forms of journalism that are both more constructive and more empowering
to Indigenous communities affected by the environmental crises
Committee: Victoria LaPoe (Advisor)
Subjects: Environmental Justice; Journalism; Mass Media; Native Americans