PhD, University of Cincinnati, 2017, Arts and Sciences: Germanic Languages and Literature
In this dissertation I focus on two types of genre fiction as viewed through the lens of Kantian ethics and social contract theory. The two types of genre fiction include detective novels written by a German speaking Swiss author named Friedrich Durrenmatt, as well as two spy novels by John le Carre. All of these novels are set in the second half of the twentieth century and in le Carre's case, during the height of the Cold War. Durrenmatt is well-known throughout the German literary canon for both his plays and his prose. I argue that he tends to differ from other writers of detective fiction because he focuses less on the mystery of the murder itself and more on the interaction of the characters, as well as the philosophical ramifications of what is happening in the story. The first Durrenmatt novel, Justiz, focuses on the conflict between a failed lawyer, named Spat, and an influential member of Swiss high-society, Dr.h.c. Isaak Kohler, who has been convicted of shooting his friend, Dr. Winter, in a crowded restaurant. This novel focuses on Spat's tortured quest for justice, in that Kohler is able to elude justice. This first chapter sets up the idea of the Kantian hero and Kantian villain. Kantian heroes and villains differ from conventional heroes and villains in that they are judged not by conventional standards but by ideas of duty, or deontologically based ethics, as well as how they treat the inherent dignity of their fellow humans. This conflict between Kantian hero and villain continues into the second chapter, which is also a detective novel by Durrenmatt, called Der Richter und sein Henker. The villain in this story is just as villainous as the hero is heroic, and again I will work with Kantian ideas of ethics to enhance the ideas of what makes a hero or villain. By this point it will be the case that conventional methods of defining heroes and villains are quite different from Kantian standards. In the third chapter, I bring in the spy fiction of John (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Harold Herzog Ph.D. (Committee Chair); Werner Jung Ph.D. (Committee Member); Tanja Nusser Ph.D. (Committee Member); Richard Schade Ph.D. (Committee Member)
Subjects: Germanic Literature