Doctor of Philosophy, The Ohio State University, 2011, EDU Teaching and Learning
This research documents the use of a pedagogy called dramatic inquiry (Edmiston, 2011) and active, rehearsal room approaches to reading Shakespeare (Royal Shakespeare Company Toolkit, 2010) in one third grade classroom during the 2010-2011 school year. Simultaneously, this research describes reading events built around the skills-based models of reading instruction while it also documents the introduction of a new way of structuring reading events in the same classroom using multiple ways of knowing beyond verbal and abstract (e.g. dramatic play, somatic, kinesthetic, gestural, musical, etc.). The findings describe the key linkages between changes in reading instruction towards dramatic inquiry and the changes in ELLs access to academic literacy and expanded repertoires for meaning-making.
Critical social cultural theories of literacy education (Lewis, Enciso, & Moje, 2007) and a performative view on social life (Goffman, 1959) and education (Alexander, Anderson, & Gallegos, 2005) informed this performance ethnography and case studies of ELLs. Multiple ethnographic data collection methods were used across the school year during both non-dramatic and dramatic practices including; field notes, researcher journal, video-coded data, student artifacts, ethnographically grounded assessments, focus groups, interviews and informal reflections with the teacher and focal students. Data analysis relied on grounded theory (Glaser & Straus, 1967) and was informed by a priori theories of drama, reading, and ELL literacy education. It employed data reduction methods through constant comparative charts, photo analysis of movement and embodied meaning, and visual data maps of related events and word knowledge.
Non-dramatic reading practices (e.g. reading group, word study) created a classroom culture of comparing reading skills. These practices were characterized by performances of knowing with inauthentic reading tasks, transmission teaching models, individual displays of fluenc (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Brian Edmiston (Advisor); Patricia Enciso (Advisor); Leslie Moore (Committee Member)
Subjects: