Doctor of Philosophy, The Ohio State University, 2018, EDU Teaching and Learning
The purpose of this study is to examine the mechanisms by which domination and resistance operate within suburban schooling spaces. Situated within a body of research focused on power, resistance, and social justice leadership in education, the author explores the following question: How can district administrators utilize autoethnographic research to name expressions of power and illuminate avenues for resistance within schooling spaces? Two theoretical frameworks guide the analysis within this dissertation: Amy Allen's Rethinking Power (1998) and Meyerson and Scully's Tempered Radicalism (1995). Written from the unique perspective of a district administrator supporting work around diversity, equity, inclusion, and curriculum, this dissertation utilizes autoethnography coupled with grounded theory methods to capture interactions, observations, and reflections that reveal practices of domination. The primary source of data for this dissertation was the author's journal, which was written over the course of sixteen months.
After engaging in an extensive incident-by-incident coding process, the analysis revealed two major findings. First, the data demonstrates that acts of domination and acts of resistance operate simultaneously and oppositionally within suburban districts. Vignettes are utilized to demonstrate the routine and unconsidered ways in which power is enacted within school systems, while also revealing how resistance is employed as a response to acts of domination, marginalization, and oppression. When faced with dominating behaviors, policies, and practices, the author captures three primary responses: disengagement (e.g., self-silencing), fear, and active resistance. Concurrently, when presented with acts of resistance, teachers and district leadership members showcased two common reactions: re-centering the majority voice and placing blame outside themselves. Second, the data suggests that there are multiple avenues of resistance that provide possibi (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Cynthia Tyson (Advisor); Antoinette Errante (Committee Member); Timothy San Pedro (Committee Member)
Subjects: Education; Educational Leadership; Multicultural Education