MCP, University of Cincinnati, 2001, Design, Architecture, Art, and Planning : Community Planning
The Main Street Approach is increasingly used to meet conventional economic development goals, as urban neighborhoods in several cities have gained Main Street programs. Bringing Main Street and conventional economic development programs in closer contact makes it necessary to evaluate the fundamental relationships between the two approaches. A new model, a Main Street program operating as a part of an urban Community Development Corporation (CDC), may serve as an object lesson. A program theory evaluation, which is a necessary first stage in a comprehensive evaluation, is an examination of the beliefs and expectations of a program and their logical relationship to the program's methods. Without a program theory assessment, it is impossible to determine conclusively whether any impacts noted result from the methods' meeting the objectives of the program theory or from other circumstances. In this thesis, the program theories of the Main Street Approach and conventional economic development are assessed and compared, as are the Main Street Approach and urban CDCs. These comparisons illuminate internal tensions within an individual program theory. They also demonstrates areas of synergy, where the two approaches can benefit each other, as well as points of potential tension, where the two approaches may find themselves in conflict. Based on the program theory evaluation, Main Street and conventional economic development programs, particularly CDCs, are likely to find several opportunities to complement each other, as well as some issues on which they will need to negotiate deep differences. Each program has the potential to benefit the other on points that range from administrative duties to offsetting internal tensions in their program theories, but program proponents will also find that their respective understanding of the problem and purpose differ significantly. This thesis recommends that proponents of both approaches improve their understanding of the others' p (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Johanna Looye (Advisor)
Subjects: Urban and Regional Planning