Doctor of Philosophy, The Ohio State University, 2014, EDU Teaching and Learning
This dissertation is a study of “non-college bound” student's perceptions of their educational experiences at one rural high school, as investigated through their narrative engagements, namely their class assignments, conversational interviews, and the creation of a digital story (Lambert, 2009). Using a theoretical framework of critical multiculturalism (May & Sleeter, 2010), and narrative inquiry as my methodology (Clandinin & Connelly, 2000), I examine the student's stories as meaningful contributions to current knowledge about issues in education such as the relevance of standardized curriculum, college access and readiness, and educational inequity.
Analyzing the narrative engagements of three students in particular - Greg, Claire and Alexa - revealed the complex and complicated ways in which students reflected on who they are, how they see themselves, and how they view their future aspirations. For all three of these students, their narratives relate to both their current day selves and their future selves and touch on the journeys that they must take to get to one from the other. For Greg, formal education is seen as irrelevant. For Claire, college is unnecessary, though training for her trade is essential and something she is planning to pursue. For Alexa, college and a 2-year medical licensure is her selected route to “become everything I ever wanted to be.”
Collectively, my analysis of data exposes the ways in which some students are not fully encouraged to pursue their driving passions (e.g., racecar driving, cosmetology) as they participate in academic opportunities (e.g., preparing to attend college), and I conclude that educators—to include teachers, teacher educators, researchers and school administrators—should reflect on how meaning is assigned to activities (that get labeled as academic and/or social activities) by re-evaluating the goals and purposes of education for students like Greg, Claire, Alexa, and their peers.
In this work, th (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Valerie Kinloch PhD (Advisor); Candace Stout PhD (Committee Member); Cynthia Selfe PhD (Committee Member)
Subjects: Education