Doctor of Philosophy, The Ohio State University, 2015, Agricultural and Extension Education
Collegiate animal sciences curricula have incorporated livestock judging since the late 19th century. Methods to assess the value of livestock have become more precise than visual appraisal over time, which contributed to a de-emphasis on training for visually evaluating livestock quality. However, data-based livestock appraisal methods can lead to single-trait selection at the expense of immeasurable traits such as structural correctness, udder quality, animal health and well-being, and physical abnormalities. As a result, visual appraisal has remained a highly utilized and valuable livestock evaluation technique in order to minimize the impact of unintended consequences from objective-only measurement criteria. Therefore, livestock producers may want to consider using both visual appraisal and data-based criteria in selection decisions. Even so, there is increased economic scrutiny within higher education, which has compounded the pressure to evaluate the utility and cost effectiveness of academic programs such as collegiate livestock judging.
The purpose of this study was to describe current sources of support and expenditures, anticipated support trends, and characteristics of collegiate livestock judging programs at four-year colleges and universities in the United States. This descriptive study used correlation and regression analysis to determine the association between livestock judging program support, expenditures, structural and demographic characteristics, and contest performance. The target population was comprised of livestock judging programs at four-year colleges and universities whose livestock judging teams had competed at the NAILE in 2012, 2013, or both years. Data collection was completed using an online survey instrument.
Findings focused on sources of funding support and categories of expenditures of four-year college and university livestock judging programs, espoused stakeholder group support for livestock judging programs (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Robert Birkenholz (Advisor); Jeffrey King (Committee Member); Gary Straquadine (Committee Member)
Subjects: Agricultural Education; Animal Sciences