PHD, Kent State University, 2008, College of Arts and Sciences / Department of Psychological Sciences
The frequency, nature, and effects of naturally occurring appearance-focused socialcomparisons on affect, cognitions, and disordered eating is an important link to our
understanding of the development of eating disorders. Most research investigating this
phenomenon has used either survey or analogue studies. While such approaches are
useful, the generalizability of the findings of such studies to more naturally occurring
comparisons is limited. Furthermore, the one study (Leahey et al., 2007) that
investigated naturally occurring appearance comparisons did not examine theoretically
relevant moderators of comparison effects (i.e., comparison motive and comparison
target). Thus, this study replicated and extended previous findings by investigating the
frequency, nature, effects, and moderators of naturally occurring appearance comparisons
on women with high body dissatisfaction and eating pathology (EDHB; n=55), high body
dissatisfaction (HB; n=45), and low body dissatisfaction (LB; n=60). Participants were
pre-screened for eating pathology and high or low body dissatisfaction during General
Psychology Mass Testing Sessions. Those who agreed to participate completed diaries
over the course of five days whenever signaled to do so by an alarm from a PDA.
Participants completed a "Comparison Diary" or a "No Comparison Diary" depending on
if they engaged in a comparison. The Comparison Diary assessed comparison direction,
effects, motive, and target and post-comparison affect, esteem, and eating-related
cognitions and behavior. The No Comparison Diary assessed general affect, esteem, and
eating-related cognitions and behavior. Intraindividual and group differences were
examined and moderators of comparison effects were explored. EDHB and HB women
engaged in more comparisons and more upward comparisons than LB women. All
women experienced negative emotional and cognitive effects of upward comparisons;
however, women with body dissatisfaction and eating pathology experience (open full item for complete abstract)
Committee: Janis Crowther PhD (Committee Chair); Nancy Docherty PhD (Committee Member); John Gunstad PhD (Committee Member); Kristin Mickelson PhD (Committee Member); Amy Kroska PhD (Committee Member)
Subjects: Psychology; Social Psychology